Well, I got my car back. I'm not 100% happy - it's not perfect, there are still 3 chips (hood, bumper and roof), all of which were supposedly repainted (hood for sure, since it's new - so why is there a chip there?). A few other blemishes that can probably be buffed out. The 2 A-pillars look perfect (had 4 or 5 chips each). Supposedly doors were painted/blended, and it actually looks fine. The color match looks to be spot-on - I did my best when comparing it to a new CX-5 off the showroom floor that the service manager parked next to mine. No loose body panels - if anything was taken apart, it looks like it was put back together again properly. One glaring issue was the bottom of the new hood. Neither I nor the service manager knows how a hood ordered as a replacement comes from Mazda (bare metal? only primer? primer and base coat?), but it looked like it had gotten the thinnest coat of paint I've ever seen on a car. I compared it to the new CX-5, and it clearly needs to be re-sprayed - they clearly did not look the same. Finally, the inside of my car was covered in body shop dust/dirt. Service manager was cleaning it as I was inspecting my car.
Service manager said he'll get back to me in a few days after he talks to Mazda and the body shop about addressing the above issues. I have no idea if that means an additional few days or weeks of not having my car again
He also said after 30 days (after the paint fully cures), he'll give me a full detail. I'll be cleaning the inside of my car this weekend as I can't drive around with it in this condition.
Finally, I did hear back from Mazda via email about all my questions and concerns, the 2 main ones being the fact that my car still has defective paint on it, and the issue of diminished value. All I'll say at this point, as a couple of other folks here have pointed out, is that Mazda doesn't care. And if you think Mazda is in some way going to compensate you in some lavish way - a buyback, a replacement vehicle, cash, etc. - you're kidding yourself. There really needs to be a class action initiated against Mazda regarding the paint issue. These vehicles should be FULLY repainted, at the least. Can't help but think about Kia and their handling of the Stinger paint issue. I feel that, at the least, those of us who have had to go through this paint issue should get a 100k/10-year bumper-to-bumper warranty extension. I don't think that would cost Mazda too much.