Tough choice.
I had a 1 car garage town house for 2.5 years and have now been in my house without a garage for 3 years.
For the amount of money I pay per month, I would greatly like to have my town house back.
Realisticly, a free standing house with some land of similar size and features to a town house is going to cost a lot more money.
So its often a really nice town house vs a house that needs some work.
That's my situation.
Mowing the lawn is pain but its not the only thing to think about. Here's what sucks at least in my opinion as I have about a half acre that is yard:
1. Planting and trying to maintain grass. This means furtalizering 3 times a year, watering twice a week for the right amount of time depending on conditions, and raking..raking..raking. GOD RAKING SUCKS. Pine trees also suck.
2. SNOW REMOVAL!!!!!!!!!! Buy a snow blower and deal with the damn city plows that LOVE to push a snow bank back into your drive way not 10 minutes after you are done clearing it.
3. Landscaping. Unless you like trees with needles on them and only trees with needles, you are gonna be doing a fair amount of weeding, watering, planting, and probably mulching.
Other things that suck about a house:
1. Pipes break..your problem
2. Roof leaks...your problem
3. deck rots off the house because original owner never stained or sealed it...your problem.
4. Siding looks like crap or is damaged...your problem.
It is nice to have a yard for the dogs and stuff but other then maintaining it, I am never out there so whats the point.
There are some benefits though.
1. not tossing money away into "condo fees" every month. For me these were over $200/month.
2. Not paying property taxes on a condo that has no property that is actually yours.
3. you can be as loud as you like. Both with stereo's and with the little lady. (boobs)
That was a HUGE problem for me in the condo....I am not talking about the stereo.
4. You can do whatever you want to the house. In a condo anything to the exterior of the building is simply not your decision and you get very few options on any such topic from the condo association.
5. Your neighbors might be douch bags and you are stuck with them unless you move.