1. What other vehicles have you considered? Volvo XC-90 (but is VERY maintenance heavy, in the shop all the time), Subaru Tribeca (parts are expensive and not immediately available, and reviews aren't that great), GM Lambda vehicle - Acadia, Traverse, Enclave, Outlook. But they are GM so they got crossed off my list. Audi Q7 - like the Volvo, maintenance heavy, not that reliable, resale value is horrible, doesn't seem that nice for an Audi, does not have a long shelf life. Minivan - just out of the question. Jeep Grand Cherokee - not out yet when I got a CX-9, Highlander - Terrible seats, 3rd row is a joke, Toyota egg smell to this day on new vehicles.
2. Why did you choose the CX-9? Drives great, reliable, looks, value, 3rd row can seat adults, it's cool, GT has xenon lights & 20 inch wheels, plus it is made in Japan.
3. If you would do it over, would you choose the CX-9 again? It would largely depend on the horsepower and gas mileage. Rumor mill has it the next one gets a four banger, which would be crossed off my list completely. However, the current engine sucks gas like no other, so I'm not sure. Gas is eating us up.
4. What do you hate/dislike about the CX-9? The passenger front seat height is non-adjustable, and sits pretty high. The exhaust has no music so all you hear is the engine, The power liftgate lifting bar has a fatal flaw and when over-used, the bar rips the metal off the gate of some folk's CX-9. Gas mileage sucks, the seats are very supportive, but when you wiggle them left/right, they don't seem very sturdy - I'm worried about how they react in an accident. Toyota seats while zero support, seem very sturdy.
5. What do you love about the CX-9? Handling, horsepower, 20 inch wheels, xenon lamps (gt model), 3rd row, cargo space, suspension/steering is awesome, very quiet cabin (tires help this)
6. What would you like to change about the CX-9? Biggest thing is the front passenger seat.
7. How's the ride quality (suspension, handling), and have you encountered any noise issues (internally and externally)? Ride quality is rock solid. GT model has 245/50/20 tires so you get a bit more feedback than sport or touring model. I would say though that it is much more tight and responsive compared to other vehicles in a similar category. The driver door trim panel squeaks like no other. Just driving down the road, the driver trim panel plastic rubs against the clearcoat on the doorshell and makes an annoying squeak. There is a diy thread on here for fixing that.