In my 2014 FWD I could hit up to 37 mpg on highway runs easily up until I had the trans swapped out at 32k miles, then I couldn't get past 32/33 highway. Still don't know if it was due to age or the trans swap. All around average for me was 30ish. My AWD I'm averaging around 27/28 and I'm at 1500 miles, haven't taken it on a trip yet but I expect to do slightly better. I'm getting as good as I was expecting and am quite pleased with my choice of AWD this time around.
Was your 14 2.0L?