This begs the question...why did you have a CX-5, anyway? The CX-5 is a worse vehicle in every way unless:
-interior space
-ground clearance
I am also in my 30s. My reasons are as follows, determined after doing test drives, renting and using all contenders.
- Honda CRV
Discarded as priced with equal options $4000 as per negotiated/Costco quote.
Discarded due to dislike of transmission.
Really liked its interior features above CX-5
- Toyota RAV4
Discarded as does not offer options I need and available in CX-5, GT with ActiveSense.
Bland looking - discarded.
Significantly better in reliability/cost of parts.
- Nissan Rougue
Almost a tie with CX-5, especially the 3rd. row seating option when balancing with features in CX-5
Ultimately, CX-5 won, purely because it felt more ALIVE when I drove it, in comparison to Rouge.
As was a tie, did some off-roading and its much worse than CX-5.
- Porche Macan AWD
- BMW X3 xDrive
- Acura RDX 4WD
These 3 are way above my price point but nevertheless looked into them to see how CX-5 compares to Macan and X3 when it comes to its oft touted road handling. Yes, I did find Macan much better, X3 - not really. RDX to compare interiors with CX-5. RDX won but does not justify the premium cost. All 3 - for noise level comparion to CX-5 and HIGH SPEED handling.
Thus - CX-5 (for me) is better in
- Features made available at the price point
- Road handling in comparison to similar priced cars in CUV segment
- Better interiors than most except CR-V
- Ground clearance/off-road in comparison to similar category CUV segment.
- Amazingly better looking.
- Actually found better rear seating space than most I tried.
What I did NOT consider - is Subaru Forrester or Outback as had bad experience with Subaru twice. Automatic discard.
Reasons for choosing a CUV:
- Already have a Toyota Corolla 2007 sedan which has coil overs, upgraded suspension components, 17' wheels and which I maintain myself. It's an amazingly reliable and easy car and love it. Has approx. 200k miles and only thing I changed were spark plugs, brake components (i mean stuff that failed). Need something when I am travelling with family on long trips or hauling something.
- Have easy zero cost access to Jeep Wrangler RUBICON, so any off-roading is covered.
- My wife loves the higher seating position, offered by CUV/SUV and gives a sense of security and control
- I like it that I can see ahead and gauge traffic or when to cut into another lane....
Right now after owning the car - what's ROYALLY PISSING ME OFF:
- Penny wise, pound foolish attitude of Mazda. Quite a large set of simple features, missing
- Live/Real-time traffic.
- Realized cost of spare parts are HIGH.
- As Mazda is low volume producer not much after market parts. In comparison to my Rolla/Wrangler, i.e.