Antoine said:
You don't build a reputation like CPE has on useless parts with weak performance...The XCel setup looks top notch...Nice work (thumb)
I don't know their reputation so I can't even begin gto speak to that. For all intents and purposes a CAI is a CAI with some sort of K&N filter on the end regardless of who makes it. Makers will add their touch with nice finishing touches.
Useless parts with weak performance. I like that comment as it brings back fond memories of working at the local import performance shop pre-fast and furious. There have been many over the years. APC comes to mind.
What I would wager is the flow gain from airbox to compressor (what the CAI is) is not the bottleneck in the system of trying to make more power. As noted by the almost factory power in the higher rpm's where a freer flowing intake should be doing it's job.
I would wager that is is either from:
1) Compressor to intake manifold. Maybe even inside the manifold itself. As represented by the generous HP gains by the top mount intercooler upgrade floating around this site.
2) From turbine wheel to exhaust. Basically the downpipe. The exhaust plays into it. In my opinion not as much as a quality downpipe would help.
So, if you are looking to add power and have a couple of hundred bucks burning a hole in your pocket... I would upgrade in this order:
Top mount intercooler, downpipe with high flow cat, k&n drop in filter, fuel tuning, then if I REALLY needed to spend more $ I would look at a short ram intake.
Why get air three degrees cooler from a longer pipe that's just gonna get heated by the turbo and associated piping anyway. In the scheme of things with a turbo motor 3 degrees means squat. An improved pressure drop over the intake piping is worth loads more than 3 degrees.
The above is personal opinion but if you really think it will prove valid. It's my soapbox, my story, and I'm sticking to it.