GM Fails
(Heavily opinionated monologue, supported by factual representation)
Incorrect, boostisgood!
The new Chevrolet economy car you've made reference to is the Aveo, which isnt even built by GM-- Its a Daewoo. Anyone recall that auto maker? Even Americans as a whole didnt buy those for very long, and Daewoo was forced to withdraw from the North American market because they sucked beyond sentient comprehension. This presents as poor support for your amorous embrace of GM.
The Buick Regal is excellent, excellent, excellent in reliability; even better than the Toyota Camry, and this reality is most fantastic in my opinion! Too bad the vehicle itself is a homely boat, and its due to be replaced by the new LaCrosse, anyway. GMs most reliable vehicle is to be no more, with the reliability of new vehicles unknown.
Pontiac Aztek A real winner!
Cadillac CTS is off the charts in poor reliability, only eclipsed by the Jaguar X-Type (A Ford owned product) And Cadillac is supposed to be GMs flagship line.
Its completely true that Japanese autos have dropped in reliability, overall, compared to their previous standings, and that is as disdainful as GMs tomfoolery. Camry had reliability problems when it was first released, but thats been corrected and now Camry is near the top of all ratings, both in reliability and performance. Honda Accord? Its down from its previous Best Possible standing in reliability, but its still better than average. The Mazda6 has been extremely reliable, and well rated, from the beginning. The Mazda3 appears to offer the same characteristics. Overall Japanese makes have still not dropped to the level of GM. But lets consider the current numbers, shall we?
GM vehicles below average in reliability: 34
Toyota vehicles below average in reliability: 1
Mazda vehicles below average in reliability: 3 (These, by the way, are the Ford clone products, not Mazda designed; Mazda designed below average? Zero.)
Honda vehicles below average in reliability: 0
Nissan vehicles below average in reliability: 1
But lets forget about reliability, just for fun. How about the top 3 cars in each category for overall ratings?
Family Sedans:
1. Volkswagen Passat GLX (V6)
2. Toyota Camry XLE (V6)
3. Honda Accord EX (V6)
Large Sedans:
1. Toyota Avalon XLS
2. Buick Park Avenue Ultra
3. Lincoln Town Car Signature
Luxury Sedans:
1. Lexus LS430 (I consider this the finest production sedan, ever)
2. Mercedes-Benz S430
3. Audi A6 2.7T
Small Cars:
1. Ford Focus ZTS
2. Honda Civic EX
3. Toyota Prius
Fuel Efficient Cars:
1. Volkswagen Golf GLS TDI (manual)
2. Toyota Prius
3. Honda Civic Hybrid
Sporty Cars:
1. Ford Focus SVT
2. Subaru Impreza WRX STi
3. Mazda RX-8
Roadsters:
1. Honda S2000
2. Chevrolet Corvette Convertible
3. Porsche Boxster 2.7
Upscale Sedans:
1. Acura TL
2. BMW 330i
3. Lexus IS300
Wagons and hatchbacks:
1. Volkswagen Passat GLX 4Motion
2. Volkswagen Passat GLS (4-cyl.)
3. Audi Allroad
Minivans:
1. Toyota Sienna LE
2. Honda Odyssey EX
3. Mazda MPV ES
Small Sport-Utility Vehicles:
1. Subaru Forester 2.5 X
2. Toyota RAV4
3. Pontiac Vibe (AWD) (This is a Toyota, not a GM product, in case no one knew)
Compact Pickup Trucks:
1. Ford Explorer Sport Trac
2. Dodge Dakota SLT Plus 4.7 (V8)
3. Toyota Tacoma TRD (V6)
Full Size Pickup Trucks:
1. Chevrolet Avalanche 1500
2. Toyota Tundra SR5 4.7 (ext. cab)
3. Dodge Ram 1500 SLT 4.7 (crew cab)
Midsized sport-utility vehicles
1. Audi Allroad
2. BMW X5 4.4i
3. Lexus RX330
Large sport-utility vehicles
1. Toyota Land Cruiser
2. Nissan Armada LE
3. Toyota Sequoia Limited
So heres the score
GM: 3
Japanese makes: 25
Had enough yet?
Okay, lets then consider only the largest Japanese maker, Toyota. Toyota Vs. GM:
GM: 3
Toyota: 14
Rather talk about fuel efficient alternative vehicles?
GM: 0
Japanese makes: 3
Okay, maybe thats not fair. How about simply fuel efficiency in conventional engines?
The GM ecotec-- 2.2 liter 4 (in the Ion): 26/33
Toyota (in the Corolla) 32/40
Honda (in the Civic) 30/38
(All stats are taken from the Saturn compare web site, representing automatic transmission)
Engine reliability?
Toyota: Excellent
Honda: Excellent
GM: Unproven (new, although it hopefully will turn out well)
0-60 times?
Ion (ecotec): 10.3 sec.
Toyota Corolla: 9.8 sec.
Honda Civic: 10.3 sec.
How about overall ethics? Well, GM builds and promotes the civilian Hummer. As the ultimate poseur automobile, nothing else need be said regarding GMs lack of interest in reasonable, responsible, safe, efficient, vehicles. 10 MPG driving your power SUV around on Sunset Boulevard presents with no useful purpose beyond petty, narcissistic vanity that increases our dependence on foreign oil, chokes the air we breathe, and takes up valuable space. This alone should be enough to condemn GM forever.
There is no compelling logic behind steadfast support for GM in any category, and Japanese makers either match or beat them over and over and over again, in nearly every way. The record GM has compiled over the last 30 years doesnt bode well for future expectations, and while I actually would like to see them match or even overtake Japanese makers, good luck living to see that happen! As if you think Toyota or Honda, with their size and power, will sit by and allow their sales to be eroded by the likes of GM, this is a patent delusion of grandeur.
So when it comes to GM, you either have mediocrity in performance or mediocrity in reliability. They havent managed to put together a complete package vehicle that delivers excellent reliability AND decent performance since the early days of Saturn, and theyve let those slip now, too. The new Ion and L300 are good in reliability, theyre harsh, noisy, cheaply constructed, and primitive compared to the leading Japanese makes like Accord, Mazda3, etc.. Alternately, you could have the aforementioned highly rated Cadillac CTS, but it doesnt deliver the reliability ALL consumers should expect and demand. Compare that to Honda's flagship luxury division. The combined reliability and performance of Cadillac is laughable compared to Acura. And Lexus? It's offensive to even mention Cadillac in the same sentence with this phenomenal, superbly engineered line of fine automobiles.
But some people dont care about reliability/performance all in one package, and thats okay. If youre happy with GM, be my guest. Ill not play party to their mediocrity however. Not EVER; until theyve established a consistent record proven by hard data that shows reliability, matching efforts for fleet wide efficiency standards, and balanced performance. None of which GM currently respects. I therefore say, To Hell with them!