One of my OEM Toyos had a flat at 15k miles which was patched, but about a month ago at 32k-33k miles I came out to my car and the patch had failed. Since all 4 tires had around 4/32nds left I decided it was better to go ahead and replace all 4 rather than buy 1 new tire or attempt a patch again.
I didn't really have much of a problem with the Toyos, they were ok to me, but I wasn't wowed by them and even through Tire Rack they were very pricey to replace. I wanted to stick to the original tire size of 225/55R19 and at $194 they were $75 cheaper per tire than the Toyos. Based on the detailed testing that tire rack did (http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tests/testDisplay.jsp?ttid=189) as well as my previous experience with Continental DW tires on my BMW, I decided to go with the True Contacts. I live in Florida where snow is no concern but we get lots of rain, so something that also handled well in the rain was a key for me.
I bought the tires through Tire Rack and had the local dealer install them and align them for me. I'm having a hard time remembering what the Toyos were like brand new, but after another 1-2k miles on the True Contacts, I can say I definitely think they ride softer than the Toyos did. They also weigh 3 lbs. less per tire than the Toyos, which is an easy way to reduce some unsprung weight per corner without getting new wheels. Handling is still comparable to the Toyos when taking a sweeping off-ramp at speed or driving enthusiastically. I'm not the best judge when it comes to road noise, but they might be equal to, if not slightly quieter than the Toyos. Our cars are noisy anyways and I don't think any quality tire brand will make too much of a difference.
Overall I'm happy with them and would purchase them again.
I didn't really have much of a problem with the Toyos, they were ok to me, but I wasn't wowed by them and even through Tire Rack they were very pricey to replace. I wanted to stick to the original tire size of 225/55R19 and at $194 they were $75 cheaper per tire than the Toyos. Based on the detailed testing that tire rack did (http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tests/testDisplay.jsp?ttid=189) as well as my previous experience with Continental DW tires on my BMW, I decided to go with the True Contacts. I live in Florida where snow is no concern but we get lots of rain, so something that also handled well in the rain was a key for me.
I bought the tires through Tire Rack and had the local dealer install them and align them for me. I'm having a hard time remembering what the Toyos were like brand new, but after another 1-2k miles on the True Contacts, I can say I definitely think they ride softer than the Toyos did. They also weigh 3 lbs. less per tire than the Toyos, which is an easy way to reduce some unsprung weight per corner without getting new wheels. Handling is still comparable to the Toyos when taking a sweeping off-ramp at speed or driving enthusiastically. I'm not the best judge when it comes to road noise, but they might be equal to, if not slightly quieter than the Toyos. Our cars are noisy anyways and I don't think any quality tire brand will make too much of a difference.
Overall I'm happy with them and would purchase them again.
Last edited: