Personal preference on mats, do wut u do. Never had issue with wt and went with the rubber all weather, not plasticky floor liners. Wife's car so no offroad action like my truck and much better than the oem carpeted ones. I don’t live in snowy area and this won't be a beach car either. I mostly don't want her heels wearing holes in the oems. when something works as good and lasts as long as the 14yr old wt ones in my truck then it might catch my attention. i have tried several other types and brands in other cars and in the end, several do the job quite well. roll with what works.....