I was doing the same to our 1998 Honda CR-V with 174,297 miles and other cars. But two years ago the CR-V had the CEL and the code says one of the possible causes is saturated charcoal canister. Since a new canister is pretty pricy for an old car, I decided to try not topping off and see. The CEL came back twice but then hasn't come back since (knock on wood). I don't know if it's Honda thing, and you have an Integra, but I don't do topping off to the brim anymore but I do make it to the even dollar amount if possible.
The auto shut-off mechanism failed on me many times, especially when I was trying to top off slowly! What a mess! Another reason I don't do topping off to the brim anymore.