I recently bought an '09 CX-9. After the poor reviews of the duellers, I had all tires siped at Discount for $52. First snow in Denver, CO today. Mixture of ice, slush, and snow. Even trying to drive like an idiot, was able to maintain control in all conditions. Would slide around corners if I floored it, but was able to correct by steering throught it. Slamming on brakes resulted in slight sliding, but able to stop in a reasonable time. Driving like one should in adverse conditions, no problems. Car has 2000 miles on it. I don't know how older tires would respond, but it might be worth spending $52 instead of $800 or more.