I just finished putting in OEM all weather mats for the front, 2nd and 3rd rows. Has it been documented how annoying it is to "install" the 2nd and 3rd row mats? Where the OEM carpeted mats have credit card sized tabs that slide right under the seat tracks, the all weather mats have much longer and much thicker rubber tabs that must be crammed under the tracks. This is my first experience with this type of design but it's a major pain. It takes some prying and pushing and shoving to get each of the mats into place. Since each of the tracks is somewhat different, there isn't too much learning that can be applied from one to the next. Some go easier than others but it takes longer than you would expect. I'm not even sure how necessary these tabs are because the mats are pretty heavy and are perfectly sized so I don't see them sliding around too much. If that was a concern, they could have used hooks and holes like they do for the front mats and saved a lot of aggravation. I will be cleaning and vacuuming around these mats rather than removing them because the hassle is just to great.
All venting aside, the mats look and fit great. They are a little less heavy duty than in my prior car (Subaru Legacy GT) and they are not terribly deep but they should contain typical mud and snow without problems. I probably would have gone with Weathertech if they had a legitimate option for the 2nd and 3rd row.