Renesis8 said:
The MS6 is heavier than the STi/EVO. Dont forget that.
I have not forgotten that. 250-300lbs more. Even if I were to add 300lbs of passengers, it would still not be as fast from my personal experience. Most bone stock dynos on the STI show 235-240 whp on average, and about 250-255 wtq. It's just logical that the dyno is pretty generous because 10-15 more whp and 25-40 more wtq for the Speed 6 just doesn't add up to 250-300lbs more weight and a full second slower in magazine times. On a base average, 100lbs = one tenth of a second in 1/4 mile.
The problem is that all different types of dynos are not the same in how they measure hp, and on a different dyno this person could end up seeing 220-225whp, as others have shown. I don't trust dynos because of the large dicrepency, as they are not truly accurate at all. I can only go by what I have driven and owned, and compare. I lost a noticable amount of power regardless of weight, but then again I'm only going by my experience, and road tests. However, it makes a pretty good argument no doubt.
A better comparison is the Legacy GT. There's only about a 140lb difference in weight, and that car is rated at 243 flywheel hp and 241 tq. That car has run high 13s in road tests, and to me feels slightly faster the time I got one as a loaner when my STI was in for inspection and an oil change, and later test drove one before purchasing my Speed 6. One can argue that the Legacy is underrated of course, but I've generally seen dynos in the 220whp- 230wtq range on that car, and it's neck and neck, if not a slight bit faster then the Speed6 if for no other reason then the weight. I also am aware that the AWD system, the tuning, and the gearbox in Subarus is superior to that of the Speed 6, so there's arguments to be made all across the boards.